• Home
  • News
  • Bulker blamed for two Suez Canal collisions in 13 hours- TradeWinds
  • 2022 November 14 17:06

    Bulker blamed for two Suez Canal collisions in 13 hours- TradeWinds

    A panamax bulker was involved in two collisions just 13 hours apart in the Suez canal after failing to moor properly after the first pile-up, a London judge has ruled, according to TradeWinds.

    The damaged 74,200-dwt bulker Alexander (built 2001) swung out from her moorings just as a convoy of northbound ships was preparing to pass on one of the narrowest stretches of the canal on 16 July 2018.

    The NYK Line-managed, 9,040-teu containership NYK Orpheus (built 2008) nearly managed to stop before striking the Alexander but had been sailing too fast and had an inadequate lookout, said Mr Justice Andrew Baker in a ruling in London’s Admiralty Courts.

    The Alexander, owned by Pacific Pearl, had been moored up at the side of the canal after its propeller and rudder were damaged in a three-ship collision the previous day.

    The Suez Canal Authority gave permission for the convoy to pass the vessel and two tugs that were due to tow the damaged Alexander.

    Two ships passed safely but the third was travelling too fast, causing the Alexander to break its mooring, according to documents. The stern of the vessel swung out into the canal and was hit by the Orpheus, the fourth vessel in the convoy, puncturing a cargo hold and ballast tank.

    The judge ruled that the Alexander had been negligent in using only six mooring lines instead of 10 – and the crew failed to quickly raise the alarm when they realised that something was going wrong.

    “Alexander’s imprudently inadequate mooring is the root cause of all that followed and was a serious failure of good seamanship on board that stricken ship,” the judge said in his ruling.

    “Had Alexander been properly moored, she would not have broken free so as to become a danger to Orpheus.”

    A court in 2020 found that the Alexander was 100% to blame for the initial collision after failing to stop in time after another vessel on the eight-ship convoy grounded after suffering mechanical problems.

    Lawyers acting for the Alexander say the boxships in the convoy the following day should have waited until the bulker was towed away before passing through the canal.

    They also claimed that the Orpheus and the ship that preceded it, the 14,026-teu NYK Falcon (built 2017), were travelling too quickly.

    Mr Justice Baker said on Friday that the Alexander and the Orpheus should pay 42% of the damages to the other ship. He ruled that the Falcon played a lesser role in the collision but should pay 17% of the Alexander’s damages.

    But he also raised concerns about the seamanship of the three vessels and found that officers were “passive and insufficiently in command” as they were “blindly” following the instructions of the Suez pilots.

    Concerns expressed by the pilots about passing the Alexander were not passed on or discussed with the ships’ officers, partly because of language difficulties, said the judge.

    The stretch of the canal gained international notoriety three years after the Alexander’s collisions when the 20,388-teu Ever Given (built 2018) grounded and blocked the waterway for six days, causing major disruptions to world trade.

    A court hearing in Egypt last year was told that two pilots of the Suez Canal Authority (SCA) on the bridge of the Ever Given argued about the ship’s passage through the canal.

2023 March 30

12:58 Alfa Laval joins the Global CCS Institute
12:46 USC’s Lotos Shipyard starts cutting steel for lead container ship of Project 00108
12:22 Sergey Kulikov appointed as General Director of Russian Maritime Register of Shipping
12:01 MAN Energy Solutions’ MAN 49/60DF engine receives Type Approval
11:45 Dredging works commenced on Volga-Caspian Canal
11:33 Port of Houston container volumes up 15% in February 2023
11:04 VARD Electro AS signs multi-million-euro project with Yaskawa Environmental Energy / The Switch
10:41 Global long-term container rates down by 24% since August 2022 - Xeneta
10:23 RC Dock receives Class Approval from RINA for new remotely controlled unmanned workboats
10:11 RosGeo invested about RUB 500 million in equipment of ships in 2022
09:58 The Maritime and Port Authority of Singapore сollaborates with Bluenergy Solutions to launch Proof of Value project for clean tidal energy
09:24 Ordering of special ships for tourism is easier than modernization of research vessels for cruises - RosGeo

2023 March 29

19:28 The problem of excess stock in Russia’s Far Eastern ports is settled – Vladimir Putin
18:37 ABP and Sizewell C plan to develop Direct Air Capture facility at Port of Lowestoft
18:06 Port of Savannah adds 55 hybrid yard cranes
17:46 ADNOC LS unveils Integrated Logistics Services Platform
17:30 Roundtable meeting “Working professions in seaports” to be held in online format on 25 April 2023
17:16 Inland ports welcome a a deal on the requirements for Alternative Fuel Infrastructure
17:03 Rosneft Oil Company and Indian Oil Company sign agreement to substantially increase oil supplies
16:49 IMO CARES project receives a further round of funding from the Kingdom of Saudi Arabia
16:31 Poseidon Acquisition acquires all of the outstanding common shares of Atlas
16:26 DP World expands offering at the Port of Berbera in Somaliland with new edible oil terminal
16:14 Fuel oil and VGO shipments from Russian ports to Singapore and Malaysia could exceed 1.1 million metric tonnes in March
15:43 Moín Container Terminal receives its third largest vessel
15:27 Russian Railways to increase Eastern Polygon capacity by 9.5% this year
15:13 Syria port authority shuts all ports due to bad weather - Reuters
14:59 USC General Director named flammability and price of composite materials as key factors hindering their use in shipbuilding
14:12 ICS publishes new landmark practical medical guide
13:42 Wartsila to supply the engines for Celebrity Cruises’ new ship
13:23 Lead bulkers for grain exports to be launched in 2025-2026 — Rosagroleasing
13:12 DNV upgrades AFI platform to promote data-sharing and accelerate transition to zero-carbon shipping
12:42 GTT entrusted by Samsung Heavy Industries with the tank design of a new Floating Liquified Natural Gas unit
12:08 Eight new LNG carriers will feature Wartsila reliquefaction systems
11:36 NYK to make Mitsubishi Ore Transport its wholly-owned subsidiary
11:12 Tianjin Port Development announces 2022 results
11:00 DP World opens one-stop refrigerated container facility in Sydney
10:56 Belarus exports its cargo via 20 Russian ports at preferential tariffs – PM Roman Golovchenko
10:45 Greek fleet shrinks for the first time since 2018
10:14 “K” Line announces the launching of demonstration test ship for liquefied CO2 transportation
10:07 Russia and India to consider joint use of Northern Sea Route for cargo transportation to Europe
09:25 USC prepared documentation for financial recovery programme

2023 March 28

18:00 Rosatom suggests replacement of floating power unit Akademik Lomonosov with more powerful one — Yury Trutnev
17:36 CLIA and ECSA issue statement on the Renewable Energy Directive
17:06 China Energy establishes shipping company
16:53 Oil supplies from Russia to India surged 22 times in 2022 — Aleksandr Novak
16:28 Rosatom suggests that oil companies transport some of their cargo by NSR
16:23 Norsepower secures €28 million from investors to bring sails back to shipping
16:05 MEYER RE and Damen Shiprepair sign cooperation agreement
15:46 Monjasa oil tanker boarded by pirates in the Gulf of Guinea
15:24 Equinor announces two rig contracts and a collaboration agreement with Transocean
15:15 Delivery of some rescue ships intended for the Arctic can be delayed by a year and a half— head of Rosmorrechflot
14:51 IMO GHG working group progresses work on revision of IMO climate strategy
14:30 Oboronlogistics counts on 20-pct increase of cargo transportation in cars by Ust-Luga - Baltiysk railway ferry line
14:21 Aramco JV HAPCO to commence construction of major refinery and petrochemical complex in China
14:07 Oboronlogistics’ Ambal ferry to leave for scheduled repairs in the second half of the summer
13:42 The world’s first floating wind fishing integrated platform design receives authoritative certification
13:19 Mitsubishi Shipbuilding holds launch ceremony in Shimonoseki for demonstration test ship for liquefied CO2 transport
12:52 Capacity of Western Arctic seaports to reach 149.5 million tonnes by 2030
12:43 MOL and Rio Tinto to strengthen partnership for safer operation
11:40 Kawasaki Heavy Industries receives an order for an 86,700 m³ LPG-fueled LPG/ NH3 carrier