
- Home
- Relevant Topics
- With no ‘leader’ at home
-
2018 October 29
With no ‘leader’ at home
According to an opinion expressed recently, construction of Leader class icebreakers is not supported by sufficient feasibility study being just a politically driven decision. The matter is what kinds of ‘Leaders’ are to be built and what are their tasks.
Matter of size
When speaking at RF Government meeting, RF Energy Minister Alexander Novak said that construction of three Leader class icebreakers is needed for the Arctic development. In his interview with RBC, USC President Aleksey Rakhmanov expressed doubts about economic efficiency of Leader class icebreakers.
“It cannot be excluded that some design solutions will prove to be insufficient or excessive, — said the head of USC. — These tests and scientific ideas which never stop developing can call the Leader necessary into doubt.”
What are the advantages of Leader class icebreakers over, let’s say, 60 MW nuclear-powered icebreakers (LK-60) which are under construction today? First of all, it is the icebreaking capability and the width of the canal. Icebreakers of LK-60 design cannot break through four-meter thick ice. Of course, there is practically no such ice on the routes. In practice, that means the following: Leader class icebreaker would be possible to ensure commercial speed of 10 knots in 2.5-meter thick ice, which is not possible for LK-60 icebreakers. If the resources allocated for construction of a powerful icebreaker of Leader class are spent for construction of two more LK-60 icebreakers the problem of commercial speed in 2.5-meter thick ice is not solved.
No less important is the fact that LK-60 icebreakers make a canal of 34-36 meters in width and cargo ships in the convoy should have a high ice class. Leader class icebreakers are supposed to make a 55-meter-wide canal allowing for escorting larger convoys with ships featuring a lower ice class. Their ability to lead large convoys of ships gives the name to this type of icebreakers.
On the other hand, construction of a Leader class icebreaker is not cheap. It is estimated at RUB 100 billion, 2.5 times as much as the cost of LK-60.
Designing of a 120 MW icebreaker has been mentioned but there are alternatives of lower capacity and cost.
For example, Krylov State research Center has proposed an alternative of a 60 MW icebreaker able to make a 62-meter wide canal. This ship will be suitable for most of equipment installed on LK-60 icebreakers. So, the components will not cost more as they will not be unique. Construction of such an icebreaker will cost RUB 50-55 billion which is about a half of cost estimated for a 120 MW icebreaker. However, this icebreaker will not ensure a commercial speed of 10 knots in 2.5-meter thick ice which is not achievable for LK-60 either.
Thus, it is quite possible that construction of three 120 MW icebreakers will be acknowledged to be too costly. Perhaps, different types of Leader class icebreakers will be built. The need for more powerful and wider icebreakers as compared with those of LK-60 design is beyond any doubt amid the plans to increase NSR traffic to 80 million tonnes per year.
Vitaly Chernov
-
2022 June 28
https://www.offshore-energy.biz
UN coordinator urges public to help stave off ‘5th largest oil spill from a tanker in history’
The UN Resident&Humanitarian Coordinator for Yemen DavidGressly urges the world to provide the last $20million needed to start an emergency operation to prevent an oil spill from the FSO Safer...UN coordinator urges public to help stave off ‘5th largest oil spill from a tanker in history’
-
2022 June 28
https://www.hellenicshippingnews.com
Smart container fleet to expand 8-fold over the next 5 years
The global telematics enabled container equipment fleet is forecast to grow 8-fold over the next 5 years and account for 25% of global box inventories by 2026...Smart container fleet to expand 8-fold over the next 5 years
-
2022 June 28
https://www.wartsila.com
How much could Carbon capture help Shipowners meet CO2 targets?
Currently, the shipping industry is responsible for 15% of the world’s NOx emissions, 14% of the world’s SOx emissions, 2.5% of the world’s CO2 emissions...How much could Carbon capture help Shipowners meet CO2 targets?
-
2022 June 24
https://bremenports.de
The German North Sea ports close ranks
This was one of the outcomes of the first discussion session of the North German seaports in Berlin...The German North Sea ports close ranks
-
2022 June 21
https://www.offshore-energy.biz
Industry-NGO coalition calls for EU hydrogen quota for shipping
A broad coalition of energy providers, shipping companies and NGOs has called on the EU to introduce a minimum quota of at least 6% sustainable and scalable hydrogen fuels by 2030...Industry-NGO coalition calls for EU hydrogen quota for shipping
-
2022 June 21
https://splash247.com
US study sees new Arctic trade routes opening up
Projections show that by 2065, the Arctic’s navigability will increase so greatly that it could yield new trade routes in international waters giving ships alternatives to the Russian-controlled Northern Sea Route...US study sees new Arctic trade routes opening up