• Home
  • News
  • EC releases report on the viability of a financial incentive for sustainable ship recycling under the EU Ship Recycling Regulation
  • 2017 August 12 09:18

    EC releases report on the viability of a financial incentive for sustainable ship recycling under the EU Ship Recycling Regulation

    The European Commission released its report on the viability of a financial incentive for sustainable ship recycling under the EU Ship Recycling Regulation this week. Whilst it acknowledges the benefits for clean and safe ship recycling such an incentive would bring, the European Commission has decided to wait with its introduction. NGOs urge the EU to take action now as it is well documented that ship owners will with ease be able to circumvent the EU Ship Recycling Regulation by simply swapping the flag of their vessel to that of a non-EU State.

    The report of the European Commission is based on the study which was conducted by Ecorys, DNV-GL and the University of Rotterdam/Erasmus, and published at the end of 2016. The proposed instrument in the study is in the form of a licence which each ship, regardless of its flag, needs to acquire in order to enter EU ports. This licence can be bought monthly, yearly, or every 5 years, depending on the trading requirements, and will be ship-specific. At the end of the ship’s life, the money spent on buying the licences will have been put aside and can be paid back to the last owner of that ship once it is recycled at a facility which is approved according to the EU Ship Recycling Regulation. Such an incentive will offset the higher profits made when selling to substandard shipbreaking yards and ensure the proper recycling of EU-trading ships regardless of their flags.
     
    In the report published on 8 August, the European Commission sees this system of the Ship Recycling Licence as a workable solution if it is demonstrated that there are many ships that will flag out to circumvent the EU Ship Recycling Regulation, thereby weakening its effectiveness. All EU-flagged vessels will have to be recycled in an EU-approved facility starting from the end of 2018 at the latest. Only once it is clear what the effects of the EU List are on the recycling choices of shipowners, will the Commission consider whether to go ahead with introducing the Ship Recycling Licence. Therefore, if shipowners choose to recycle their vessels responsibly in a facility on the EU List and do not flag out in order to circumvent the Ship Recycling Regulation, the Commission believes that it will not be necessary to introduce a financial mechanism.

    However, flagging out at end-of-life is a practice which is already widespread. Most shipowners sell their obsolete vessels to so-called cash buyers. These scrap-dealers become the new owners of the ships and both re-name and re-flag the vessels for their last voyage to the beaching yards in South Asia. Particularly popular registries amongst the cash buyers are the Paris MoU grey- and black-listed flags of Comoros, Palau and St. Kitts and Nevis – flags that are known for their poor implementation of laws governing labour rights and environmental protection at sea. Maersk also already threatened that it would flag out its fleet from the Danish registry if the Alang beaching yards they have recently chosen to use are not approved by the EU. Swapping the flag of a ship is easy and makes it very simple for cash buyers and shipowners to circumvent the law. The motivation for doing so is also simple: dirty and dangerous shipbreaking brings higher profits due to the lack of investments in infrastructure, illicit handling of hazardous wastes and extremely poor working conditions. For these reasons the NGO Shipbreaking Platform urges the EU Commission to not wait for the effects of the EU List, but instead show that it intends to take all measures possible to change the current deplorable shipping practices and commit now to making a legislative proposal to introduce a financial incentive.

    Legislation based on flag state jurisdiction alone is far too easy to circumvent. That is why more policies aimed at improving the social and environmental performance of shipping is being enforced via port state control. The Ship Recycling Licence is as such in line with international trade law. Taking also into account the widespread acknowledgement that financial incentives are key in ensuring the success of environmental policies, it seems obvious that a return scheme for ships is needed to change the behavior of shipowners that currently earn profits at the detriment of workers’ health and lives and the environment.


2022 October 2

11:27 North Italian terminal orders Generation 6 Konecranes Gottwald Mobile Harbor Crane to lift productivity and eco-efficiency
09:58 GTT receives an order from DSME for the tank design of ten new LNG carriers

2022 October 1

15:31 International carbon collaboration could reshape shipping markets - ICS
13:48 14% of the Port of Valencia’s electrical energy will be of solar origin
12:17 Emissions focus from charterers promises both scrutiny and support - ICS
10:43 Finnpilot Pilotage announces a 4.7% increase in pilotage fees for 2023

2022 September 30

18:05 Port of Cardiff celebrates new distribution centre lease with Owens Group
17:59 Yaroslavsky Shipbuilding Plant launches yet another multi-purpose boat of project 02220
17:28 Hoegh Autoliners offers customers carbon neutral operations
17:05 Maersk Drilling awarded contract offshore Brazil with Shell
16:57 Twelve Chinese sailors die of suspected food poisoning near Vietnam - Australian Associated Press
16:45 CMA CGM launches new early container return incentive
16:25 Kalmar’s EcoFlex rental solution to help Logent improve the sustainability of its cargo-handling activities
16:07 Container ship Sparta delivered 340 TEU of consumer goods to Baltiysk in the Kaliningrad Region
15:51 Aqaba Container Terminal announces zero-emission vision
15:27 RF Government to allocate RUB 2 billion for creation of LNG equipment prototypes
15:14 HHLA and Fraunhofer CML start IHATEC project
15:04 LR approval in principle for Maridea’s Moray Base floating wind concept
14:48 Albania implements the IMO Anti-fouling Systems Convention
14:03 Rolls-Royce and Lürssen to focus on methanol propulsion for large yachts
13:32 Successful delivery of 1800TEU container vessel M/V “ASL HONGKONG”
13:16 DNV confirms Nordseecluster wind farms will comply with German offshore regulations
13:13 Turnover of FESCO’s Far East coastal services in 8M’2022 rose by 6%, YoY
12:53 Orsted completes divestment of 50 % of Hornsea 2 Offshore Wind Farm
12:44 Handling of Belarus’ oil products in Russian ports can total 3 million tonnes in 2022
12:21 ABS and DSME team-up on decarbonization strategy
12:01 OOCL completes trial voyage with biofuel from Chevron
11:40 Ningbo Containerized Freight Index deceases by 31.0% in September 2022
11:22 POT and EMERCOM held joint firefighting exercise on oil tanker in Saint-Petersburg
11:05 Dutch fishing vessel struck anchored product tanker, oil leak
10:37 China's first 2,000-ton offshore wind power installation platform delivered in Guangzhou - China Daily
10:33 Russia convenes emergency meeting of UN Security Council on Nord Stream 1 and Nord Stream 2 gas pipeline blasts
10:09 China ports container volume rises 4.1% in January - August 2022
09:55 Delivery of second ice-class buoy laying vessel of Project BLV03 accepted in Murmansk
09:32 Crude oil futures are slightly up after a decrease at the previous session
09:32 Brazil’s CBO Group and Wartsila sign Decarbonisation Service agreement to speed up fleet sustainability
09:21 MABUX: Bunker index may turn into downward changes on Sep 30
08:34 MABUX: Bunker Weekly Outlook, Week 39, 2022

2022 September 29

18:36 Shift Clean Energy selected to electrify 17 new tugboats
18:10 Ulstein develops 8,000t foundation installation vessel
17:50 Volgotrans files suits against Lotos shipyard for over RUB 800 million in total
17:06 Vattenfall awarded major wind power project off the coast of Germany
16:44 Krasnoye Sormovo shipyard to build three cruise ships of ‘Karelia’ design
16:34 Yinson Greentech commences construction of all-electric cargo vessel
16:18 The largest shipyard in the MENA region signs a long-term agreement with Bahri Logistics
15:56 Container shipping and logistics experts Matson joins SEA-LNG
15:04 Aker Solutions joins to the Aiming for Zero Methane Emissions Initiative
14:58 Amount of cargo transported via Bosphorus rose 40% since 2005
14:36 Hoegh Autoliners joins First Movers Coalition and commits to using green fuels already by 2030
14:25 Maritime industry unites to call for earmarking of ETS revenues
13:45 Sanmar Shipyards delivers 7th tug to SAAM Towage
13:24 Port of Cork Company launches a new 13.5-hectare container terminal
12:56 Severnaya Verf shipyard launches lead factory freezer-longliner of Project MT1112XL, Gandvik-2
12:53 China delivers first VLCC equipped with four rigid sails - The Maritime Executive
12:05 Second ship of Project 03141, Kedon, left Khabarovsk Shipyard for delivery base
11:40 Mawani signs 7 agreements during the Saudi Maritime Congress
11:03 GTT receives AiP from Bureau Veritas for the design of a LNG-fuelled & “NH3 Ready” Very Large Crude Carrier
10:23 Keppel O&M secures repeat newbuild FPSO contract worth US$2.8b from Petrobras
10:10 CPC Marine Terminal handled 382 tankers by mid-September
09:48 Long-term contracted rates fell by 1.1% in September - Xeneta